Monday, October 25, 2010

Empty Staff Quarters

I do not work on Mondays; I do some lesson plans, I walk my dog, I read, I write, I go to my tennis lesson at 5.

I do not cook; Moise, a Togolese man in his 50's with three daughters, spends 2 full days a week at our house making enough food so that I never have to boil water if I don't want to. We pay him the generous salary, by Togolese standards, of 7,000 CFA ($14) per day.

I do not clean; Clara, a Ghanaian woman in her 50's with four children, spends 1 day a week here doing laundry, scrubbing our floors, vacuuming, etc. Aside from some dishes on the days when Clara or Moise aren't here and organizing of stuff, I am spared household duties for the price of 7,000 CFA as well.

Despite this ridiculous luxury by our standards, many locals think it's strange that we don't have full time staff. But I feel lazy and guilty by American standards for having said cook, cleaner and all around easy life as much as I do.

So imagine the conflicting emotions that arose last week when Clara broke down into tears about how much she is struggling right now. Her husband died years ago and her nearly grown children can't find jobs as there are so few in Togo. She only works one day a week right now because there aren't any US Embassy families who need her. We keep telling her that we'll recommend her to arriving families, but we can't make any promises.

She is living on $14 a week (sadly, still more than the average Togolese makes) and is struggling. As she cried, I became privy to a family drama that I still don't fully understand. It went like this:

"I wish I hadn't been born African. Africans have black hair, which means they have black minds," said Clara after telling me she needed to leave early to attend a court hearing about some land issues.

"There are bad people everywhere, Clara. It's not just here." I responded, taken aback by her comment.

She looked genuinely surprised. "Really Madame? There are?"

She went on to describe how her late husband's brother had been managing her money because that's how finances pass when a man dies. It doesn't go to his wife - it goes to another man. Her son wasn't yet old enough to be put on their accounts and properties as the owner, so it all went to her brother-in-law.

This man used his dead brother's money to buy a house for his family, instead of leaving it for Clara's kids' education. But this detail came after learning about her present problem. He had recently come to Togo to visit some land that Clara's husband had purchased with 2 other men. According to Clara, he put a "joojoo" spell on the land that would make it so that she would drop dead if she ever stepped foot there. He then asked her to meet him there and discuss its "true" ownership.

She refused to meet him there and was going with some of her friends to meet him at a court house to discuss the land deed. Her brother-in-law was claiming that Clara forged her husband's signature on ownership documents and somehow or another it was actually his money that purchased the land.

This is where I started getting lost in the family drama. Clara's Ghanaian English combined with all of the intricate voodoo references and incomprehensible legal structure (or lack thereof) made things very confusing very fast.

But all I know is that I had an older woman in my kitchen with tears rolling down her cheeks, desperately wanting to ask for more work to help her through this tough time. I know because I was avoiding the question.

We recently gave our cook a huge advance on his pay so that he could cover her tuition. He's paying us back over 6 months. Our gardener (yeah, we have one of those too - it's not normal, I know) was only just recently able to move out of his sister's shack because he's working 6 days a week (shared between 3 houses) on $6 a day, all the while paying for his little brother to go to school.

So where does the help begin and end, in a country where everywhere you look are people in desperate need? How can you be sure that your money will do any good at the end of the day when the family structures and cultural differences are so foreign?

And how can you reconcile suddenly being in a place where you're richer than most locals' wildest dreams, when you come from a place where you're most certainly not?

Most of us were raised on a certain moral code that taught us not to pay for things just because you can. We admire people who can live in mansions but chose not to. We respect those who can afford a full time chef but enjoy cooking for themselves anyway. Just because you can pay for a bell-hop doesn't mean you can't carry your own friggin' luggage.

More than anything though, most of us never have to make the above decisions. Life in the US is simply too expensive, and even when it's not, we all find ways of needing or wanting more and more things that make it so in the end.

But it's not like that here. People with money hire staff. Doing something yourself takes away a job from someone who needs it. People with staff quarters fill them. Leaving them empty deprives someone of a clean, dry room in a malaria and flood ridden land.

I don't need someone cleaning my house two times a week - it'd be absurd - but I can. Does that mean I should?

Joey and I have discussed possibly giving Clara an old sewing machine to help her start another revenue source, or trying to cover some of her younger kids' schooling. We'd hoped to wait a few more months to get to know her better. Mostly we just feel incredibly awkward about the whole thing.

And I can't even begin to process the implications of an African woman telling an American woman that her people are inherently bad and that she wishes she'd been born something else.

7 comments:

  1. How sad. Part of me is like do you believe them and part says how can I help. Whatever don't ever feel guilty just feel grateful. Enjoy all this while you can because there may come a day when you have to do this all yourself and wish you had it again. You and Joey are so kind. I was hoping for another blog.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow, heavy stuff, Jen. I don't even know how you begin to process their realities, much less your role in it. It's eye-opening stuff and I'm glad you're there to write about it, education us, and do something for the people you can.

    ReplyDelete
  3. p.s. on a lighter note, you're taking tennis??

    ReplyDelete
  4. Jen, You're "not in Kansas anymore". These are the facts of a disparate world. This is why generations of families have lived with the dream "if I could just get to America!" (quote from Arnold Schwazeneger as a young man in Austria, which is not exactly Togo) What all these desperate populations need is a decent government, founded on a miraculous Document, probably inspired by God. They are not going to get it. They are not equipped to accept it if it was written in triplicate and circulated to every household in the country. You and Joey are going to break your hearts trying to do what you think is right/best, and then you are going to leave Togo and go on to another location where you may encounter virtually the same circumstances. You will go better equipped personally to deal with your life out of the US, but little better equipped to help, for the simple reason that there is in fact little that you can do.

    You will leave Togo in essentially the same situation as you found it. This is tragic. For decade after decade Americans have gone and done whatever they could to help in impossible situations ...
    rebuilding, intervening politically, spending American blood and treasure, digging wells, supplying mosquito netting, medicine, technological expertise, And still the problems remain, intransigent, immovable in the face of thousands of years of voodoo spiritualism, crippling customs, and the shear weight of the thousands of preceeding years.

    Your latest post is heavy with your concern for the people around you. Remember that you will make a tiny blip on the lives of these people, not because you and Joey are not trying your best, not because your intentions are not valid, but simply because you have been given an impossible task. If you can leave these few Togolese people who are in direct contact with you, and leave them knowing there is a sweet blonde American lady who cared about them and did what little she could, you will have done your best. Your mom and dad and I learned long ago that we can't fix every broken child. You and Joey have to learn that you must be content with what you can fix, knowing that it is a tiny fraction of what you would like to accomplish. Take heart, little girl. Maybe your true job in Togo is your own personal growth...at least, that is something you have some control over. Dot

    ReplyDelete
  5. Makes one reflect on life in so many aspects. The Togolese still deal with different colliding worlds - current culture and the ancestory of life before, hence Clara's statement of having "black minds". Something that is a mindset of people's upbringing and cannot be easily changed. So Jen, your temporary life in Togo will have some impact because we all leave our footprints in the sand everywhere we go.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This makes me so sad . . . . I would feel the same way you do.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Jen & Joe,
    As I said when we Skype a couple weekends ago (yes oh so cool) thank you for letting me live vicariously through your experiences. Keep reflecting and as much as you can pass little judgment too, oh so hard to do but just being aware and listening is such a gift. Also keep sharing your thoughts with the all whom you meet because you are gaining and they are gaining such a gift for both parties. Poverty comes in many forms some are easier to see then others. You and Joe are special persons that is why you are there and thank you again for sharing!
    In Christ & Love > billy
    We ourselves feel that what we are doing is just a drop in the ocean. But the ocean would be less because of that missing drop.
    ~Mother Teresa

    ReplyDelete